Yep, we may get a tiny thank-you (read: commission) when you buy through links on Hubpickr — not enough for a yacht, but enough to keep the lights (and servers) on. Learn more
148 Highlights 53 Differences 7 Reactions 0 Likes
Printerpix vs Shutterfly: 148 Highlights & 53 Differences — So, Which Online Photo Printing Actually Works Better
Compare printing quality, customization tools, and product variety to see which platform suits your gifting style. Can’t pick the better online photo printing? Let’s break down Printerpix vs Shutterfly in plain terms with real dpi handling, bleed requirement, digital proof & proof approval required and feedback.
Printerpix vs. Shutterfly: A Detailed Photo Printing Face-Off
When considering online photo printing services, Printerpix and Shutterfly emerge as two of the most well-known and widely used options available to a diverse range of customers, including individual consumers, small business owners, and professional photographers. Both of these services offer a variety of core features that are appealing to users, such as the ability to place unlimited orders without restrictions, a selection of standard print sizes that range from as small as 4x6 inches to as large as 16x20 inches, and a suite of comprehensive customization tools that enable users to rotate, crop, and overlay text onto their images with ease.
However, despite these similarities, the two companies differ significantly in several important aspects. These include the durability of their prints, the types of file formats they support, the estimated production times for completing orders, and their efforts towards sustainability and environmentally friendly practices. Such differences allow users to make informed choices based on what features and qualities are most important to them, whether they prioritize longevity, compatibility, speed, or environmental impact.
The Durability Champion: Printerpix's Robust Print Offering
Printerpix shines with its commitment to producing long-lasting prints. Featuring water-resistant prints and archival quality materials, it ensures photos remain vibrant and protected over time. With a slightly thicker 0.6 paper weight compared to Shutterfly, images feel substantial and premium. Its use of glossy and matte lamination, along with protective sleeves, further enhances the longevity of prints.
On the service side, Printerpix offers a quicker turnaround, with a standard production time of 2-5 business days versus Shutterfly's longer 3-10 day window. Their customer support is robust, including live chat, phone, email, and a knowledge base, facilitating smoother communication. Additionally, Printerpix backs its prints with multiple guarantees: money-back, print quality, satisfaction, and reprint, which provide substantial peace of mind for users investing in cherished memories.
Sustainability and Flexibility: The Shutterfly Strengths
In contrast, Shutterfly caters to environmentally conscious users by utilizing FSC-certified materials, reinforcing its commitment to sustainable photo printing. While not water-resistant, its prints retain archival quality and use comparable dye-based color technology, ensuring vibrant results. One of its unique advantages is the support for more diverse file formats, including BMP and HEIC, which can be crucial for photographers and users working with varied image types.
Moreover, Shutterfly offers an attractive option for those who want immediate access to their prints with a pickup in-store option, something Printerpix lacks. Its longer order data retention and ability to export account data add a layer of user convenience for those wishing to manage their data over time. Though it lacks protective lamination or sleeves and does not offer money-back or print quality guarantees, Shutterfly compensates with a solid satisfaction guarantee and standard customer support channels, including email, phone, and help center.
Quick Take
Printerpix impresses with faster turnaround, superior print durability, and a wide range of finishing options like lamination and protective sleeves, combined with comprehensive guarantees. Shutterfly, meanwhile, appeals to eco-aware customers with sustainable materials, broader file format compatibility, and flexible pickup options, making it a versatile choice for different workflows.
Bottom Line
For users prioritizing archival-quality, durability, and assured print satisfaction with faster delivery, Printerpix is arguably the superior choice. However, if your focus is on sustainability, diverse file format support, and convenient in-store pickup, then Shutterfly may better suit your needs. Overall, considering price and feature balance, Printerpix tends to provide greater value to most general consumers and small business users.
Verdict
Winner: Printerpix - Offers water-resistant, laminated prints with comprehensive guarantees, faster production, and broader customer support, making it ideal for durable, high-quality photo printing.
Runner-up: Shutterfly - Great for sustainability-minded users who desire in-store pickup and support for additional file formats, but lacks the extensive guarantees and protective finishing options.
Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.
Which online photo printing is faster, easier, or more reliable? Our side-by-side look at Printerpix and Shutterfly gives you honest pros and cons before you decide.
47 Shutterfly 0Votes Consumers, Photographers, Small Businesses
vs Target Audience
The Target Audience for Framebridge consists of Consumers, Photographers, and Small Businesses, while Frameology targets Consumers exclusively, indicating Framebridge caters to a wider audience.
Identifies the main audience segments served by the platform.
In the battle of Target Audience, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Target Audience on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
55 Printerpix 0Votes File Upload, Drag & Drop, Mobile Upload
54 Shutterfly 0Votes File Upload, Drag & Drop, Mobile Upload
vs Upload Methods
Framebridge supports File Upload and Drag & Drop methods, while Frameology only supports File Upload, providing Framebridge with more flexible upload options.
Defines the supported methods for uploading photos.
In the battle of Upload Methods, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Upload Methods on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Both Framebridge and Frameology provide Archival Quality prints, meaning their products are designed to last and maintain quality over time.
Shows whether prints are designed for long-term preservation.
In the battle of Archival Quality, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 2 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Archival Quality on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Surface Texture
What surface texture do the prints have?
58 Printerpix 0Votes Smooth
57 Shutterfly 0Votes Smooth
Printerpix
Smooth surface texture creates a sleek feel and enhances image sharpness.
Shutterfly
The surface texture is described as Smooth, ideal for various printing needs from photos to professional projects.
Describes the tactile feel of the print surface.
In the battle of Surface Texture, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Surface Texture on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
White Point
What is the paper white point?
68 Printerpix 0Votes Bright White
27 Shutterfly 0Votes Neutral White
Printerpix
Bright white paper base maximizes color vibrancy and contrast for vivid prints.
Indicates the base whiteness tone of the paper.
In the battle of White Point, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 41 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the White Point on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Ink Type
What type of ink is used?
48 Printerpix 0Votes Dye Ink
47 Shutterfly 0Votes Dye Ink
Shutterfly
This service utilizes Dye Ink, known for its vibrant print quality. Alternatives include Pigment Ink and Archival Ink, which may offer different benefits.
Specifies the type of ink used in the printing process.
In the battle of Ink Type, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Ink Type on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Paper Material
What paper material is used?
83 Printerpix 0Votes Photo Paper, Canvas, Metal
87 Shutterfly 0Votes Photo Paper
Printerpix
A variety of paper materials are supported including photo paper, canvas, and metal for specialty prints.
Identifies the base material used for photo printing.
In the battle of Paper Material, Printerpix ◉ is worse than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering lower 4 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Paper Material on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Paper Weight
What is the paper weight?
0.6 lbs 0Votes
0.5 lbs 0Votes
vs Paper Weight
Framebridge uses Paper Weight of 0.5 lbs, while Frameology uses a significantly heavier 230 lbs paper weight, reflecting differences in print material robustness.
Indicates the thickness and sturdiness of the paper used.
In the battle of Paper Weight, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 0.1 lbs measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Paper Weight on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Fade Resistance Rating
How fade-resistant are the prints?
68 Printerpix 0Votes High
67 Shutterfly 0Votes High
Shutterfly
This printing service has a High fade resistance rating, ensuring that products maintain their vibrant colors over time.
Options range from Low to Archival Grade.
Shows how well prints resist fading over time.
In the battle of Fade Resistance Rating, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Fade Resistance Rating on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Color Gamut Coverage
How wide is the color gamut coverage?
48 Printerpix 0Votes Standard RGB
47 Shutterfly 0Votes Standard RGB
Describes the range of colors that can be reproduced.
In the battle of Color Gamut Coverage, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Color Gamut Coverage on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Print Resolution
What print resolution is offered?
73 Printerpix 0Votes High
47 Shutterfly 0Votes Standard
Indicates the overall print sharpness and detail level.
In the battle of Print Resolution, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 26 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Print Resolution on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Paper Finish
What paper finishes are available?
63 Printerpix 0Votes Glossy, Matte, Luster
57 Shutterfly 0Votes Glossy, Matte
Describes the surface finish of the printed photo.
In the battle of Paper Finish, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 6 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Paper Finish on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Smudge Resistance
Are the prints smudge-resistant?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Shows whether prints resist smudging when handled.
In the battle of Smudge Resistance, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 42 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Smudge Resistance on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Framebridge offers Mounting Type Options including Foam Board and Gatorboard, while Frameology only offers Foam Board, indicating more mounting variety from Framebridge.
Specifies available mounting methods.
In the battle of Mounting Type Options, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 4 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Mounting Type Options on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Mounting
Is mounting available?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
Yes 0Votes Shutterfly
Printerpix
Mounting services are offered to give prints a finished look suitable for display.
Indicates whether mounting options are offered.
In the battle of Mounting, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 2 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Mounting on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Protective Sleeve
Is a protective sleeve included?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Printerpix
Protective sleeves are included to help preserve print quality and protect from fingerprints, dust, and minor damage during handling and shipping.
Indicates whether prints include a protective sleeve.
In the battle of Protective Sleeve, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 42 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Protective Sleeve on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Lamination
Is lamination available?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Indicates whether lamination is offered to protect prints.
In the battle of Lamination, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 42 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Lamination on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
UV Coating
Is UV coating available?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Indicates whether UV coating is offered for added protection.
In the battle of UV Coating, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 42 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the UV Coating on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Matte Coating
Is matte coating available?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
Yes 0Votes Shutterfly
Shows whether a matte protective coating is available.
In the battle of Matte Coating, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 2 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Matte Coating on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Glossy Coating
Is glossy coating available?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
Yes 0Votes Shutterfly
Indicates whether a glossy protective coating is available.
In the battle of Glossy Coating, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 2 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Glossy Coating on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Frame Material Options
What frame materials are available?
43 Printerpix 0Votes Wood, Metal
50 Shutterfly 0Votes Wood, Metal, Acrylic
Lists materials available for photo frames.
In the battle of Frame Material Options, Printerpix ◉ is worse than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering lower 7 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Frame Material Options on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Edge Finish Options
What edge finish options are available?
35 Printerpix 0Votes White, Black, Wrapped
17 Shutterfly 0Votes White, Black
Describes finishing options for print edges.
In the battle of Edge Finish Options, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 18 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Edge Finish Options on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Bleed Requirement is Optional Bleed for Framebridge and No Bleed Required for Frameology, indicating Framebridge offers more flexibility with bleed options.
Indicates whether bleed margins are required.
In the battle of Bleed Requirement, Printerpix ◉ is worse than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering lower 39 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Bleed Requirement on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Shutterfly supports more file formats including BMP and HEIC which gives me more options.
See more
Recommended Resolution
What resolution is recommended?
68 Printerpix 0Votes High
67 Shutterfly 0Votes High
Printerpix
A high recommended resolution means the prints will have good detail and clarity, suitable for most photo printing needs.
Suggests the optimal resolution for best print quality.
In the battle of Recommended Resolution, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Recommended Resolution on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Filename Requirements
Are there filename requirements?
8 Printerpix 0Votes No Restrictions
27 Shutterfly 0Votes Basic Rules
Shutterfly
Filename requirements include Basic Rules, which ensure a smooth uploading process without excessive restrictions.
Describes naming rules for uploaded files.
In the battle of Filename Requirements, Printerpix ◉ is worse than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering lower 19 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Filename Requirements on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Color Profile
What color profiles are supported?
18 Printerpix 0Votes sRGB
17 Shutterfly 0Votes sRGB
Printerpix
Color profiles use sRGB, which is the most common standard for color consistency across devices and web.
Indicates which color profiles are supported.
In the battle of Color Profile, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Color Profile on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
CMYK
Is CMYK supported?
No 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Indicates whether CMYK color files are supported.
In the battle of CMYK, Printerpix ◉ is same as Shutterfly ◉ .
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the CMYK on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
RGB
Is RGB supported?
Yes 0Votes Printerpix
Yes 0Votes Shutterfly
Shows whether RGB color files are supported.
In the battle of RGB, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 2 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the RGB on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
File Cropping Rules
How are files cropped?
58 Printerpix 0Votes User Controlled
57 Shutterfly 0Votes User Controlled
Explains how images may be cropped during printing.
In the battle of File Cropping Rules, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the File Cropping Rules on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Transparency
Is transparency supported?
No 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Shows whether transparent backgrounds are supported.
In the battle of Transparency, Printerpix ◉ is same as Shutterfly ◉ .
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Transparency on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Metadata Preservation
Is image metadata preserved?
No 0Votes Printerpix
Yes 0Votes Shutterfly
vs Metadata Preservation
Metadata Preservation is not supported by either Framebridge or Frameology, so image metadata is not preserved through their systems.
Indicates whether image metadata is preserved.
In the battle of Metadata Preservation, Printerpix ◉ is worse than Shutterfly ◉ .
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Metadata Preservation on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Minimum Resolution Requirement
What is the minimum resolution requirement?
0 Printerpix 0Votes Standard
0 Shutterfly 0Votes Standard
Defines the minimum image resolution required for printing.
In the battle of Minimum Resolution Requirement, Printerpix ◉ is same as Shutterfly ◉ .
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Minimum Resolution Requirement on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Framebridge provides Exact Match Cropping Preview Accuracy, while Frameology's is Approximate, meaning Framebridge offers more reliable cropping accuracy previews.
Shows how accurately cropping previews reflect final output.
In the battle of Cropping Preview Accuracy, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Cropping Preview Accuracy on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Physical Proof
Is a physical proof available?
No 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
vs Physical Proof
Physical Proofs are not offered by either Framebridge or Frameology, so customers cannot review tangible print proofs prior to final production.
Shows whether a physical proof can be ordered.
In the battle of Physical Proof, Printerpix ◉ is same as Shutterfly ◉ .
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Physical Proof on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Monitor Calibration Guidance
Is monitor calibration guidance provided?
No 0Votes Printerpix
No 0Votes Shutterfly
Indicates whether guidance for monitor calibration is provided.
In the battle of Monitor Calibration Guidance, Printerpix ◉ is same as Shutterfly ◉ .
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Monitor Calibration Guidance on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Print Preview Accuracy
How accurate is the print preview?
73 Printerpix 0Votes Accurate
72 Shutterfly 0Votes Accurate
Indicates how closely previews match final prints.
In the battle of Print Preview Accuracy, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Print Preview Accuracy on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Reprint Policy on Errors
What is the reprint policy on errors?
48 Printerpix 0Votes Case-by-Case
47 Shutterfly 0Votes Case-by-Case
Describes how reprints are handled when errors occur.
In the battle of Reprint Policy on Errors, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Reprint Policy on Errors on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
72 Printerpix 0Votes Email, Live Chat, Phone, Help Center
65 Shutterfly 0Votes Email, Help Center, Phone
vs Customer Support Channels
Framebridge's Customer Support Channels include Email, Live Chat, and Help Center, while Frameology offers Email and Help Center only, giving Framebridge users more direct support options.
Lists the channels through which customer support is available.
In the battle of Customer Support Channels, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 7 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Customer Support Channels on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Complaint Handling Process is Dedicated Support through Framebridge and Email Based for Frameology, suggesting Framebridge may offer more specialized complaint management.
Describes how customer complaints are handled.
In the battle of Complaint Handling Process, Printerpix ◉ is better than Shutterfly ◉ , delivering higher 1 score measurement.
Don’t keep it to yourself — be the first to react and review the Complaint Handling Process on Printerpix ◉ vs Shutterfly ◉ and help others decide!
Supermod 
Moderator 
Recaptor 
